Solutions ... have thought it? has 9 entries with similar clues
- gee"Well, who'd have thought?!"
- needhave to have
- jujuObjects thought to have magical powers
- amuletObjects thought to have magical powers
- fetishObjects thought to have magical powers
- canteencan't even match a restaurant, thought it may have fine cutlery!
- pensivethoughtful writers i have briefly followed
- talismanObjects thought to have magical powers
- underdogA competitor thought to have little chance of winning